BECOMING A MOVEMENT PHOTOGRAPHER - UCLA Labor Center Interview - Part Two
Janna Shadduck-Hernandez, project director at the UCLA Labor Center, Interviewed photographer and journalist David Bacon on March 20, 2026, in Fort Bragg, CA
Grace Shimizu fighting for continued Temporary Protected Status for immigrants and against deportations in front of San Francisco's Ferry Building.
JANNA SHADDUCK-HERNANDEZ: How do you bring your particular, nuanced perspective to your photography, and how do you survive doing it?
DAVID BACON: That's the problems of being a photographer. The reason I started out broke, and stayed broke for most of the time, is that we're still working on that. What's the biggest problem for freelance writers and photographers? Money. Nobody can make a living at it, nobody can live off this work. We have to stay grounded as workers ourselves, not just operating in some rarefied realm of aesthetics and images. We have to remember that we're still workers. Media workers are workers. A photographer is a worker, a writer is a worker.
JANNA: Writers are workers - I remember when the Writers Guild went on strike in LA, so many people thought of them as just these elite writers. I was like, okay, let's hold on here. I wanted to remind you of a moment that I will never forget, that I've told so many times. We did some workshops together, maybe fifteen or twenty years ago, with some of my students, at the day-labor site under the bridge at the old Pequín's Hotel. There was a day-labor center there, not anymore. We held a series of photo sessions with day laborers and students, and you were sharing a series of photographs. There was one - I thought at first it was Dorothea Lange, but it wasn't - a car, and a bunch of people, shown at nighttime. It connects back to your story of the foundry workers organizing at night and the boss showing up.
You showed that picture, and the students, myself included, were like - well, it's nighttime, it's a dusty road, it's someplace desolate. But it's this gorgeous photo. And every single day laborer there - right away - said, that's a union meeting, those are workers, they're meeting at night. It was such a beautiful moment, because that's the power of photography - eliciting a whole series of feelings and stories from an image. Those day laborers, in this trailer under a bridge, in a very precarious day-labor site, got so animated, so excited to learn about photography, because someone was showing them a picture and then teaching them how to take pictures themselves, which you did. I've told that story so many times - it still makes me a little emotional, because it's so powerful.
DAVID: Well, the thing is, how you interpret a photograph depends a lot on what you bring to it - the experience you bring. That's the reason the day laborers could recognize more of what was going on in that photograph. It's a famous photograph, Night Meeting at the Crossroads, by Hansel Mieth and Otto Hagel. In their own experience, the day laborers could look at the people and recognize them as workers. They could look at the night and recognize it as somehow threatening.
So, you know, there are a lot of lessons in that. Photographs have context, but the context is also what you, the viewer, bring to it - the combination of the actual real-life context, where the picture was taken and why, and your own experience. There was enough of a match between the day laborers' experience and what was happening in that picture that they could understand a great deal about it. They might not have known it was specifically a union meeting, but it was obviously a meeting of workers, at night, somewhere out there.
JANNA: The lights - the car lights.
DAVID: Yeah, the headlights of the cars provided the lighting. Look at the light - that's a beautiful one. I think that's a really good lesson for any photographer, especially one who wants their pictures to carry some social value. You have to think about the context, and how much of that you can move into the image. You don't just want a picture of picket signs saying something. You need more than one kind of element in it. But you also have to think about who you're taking the picture for, and what the purpose is.
This is an ongoing discussion I have, and people like me have, with our profession, about things like neutrality and objectivity. We see ourselves as participants in the world - participants in movements for social justice. We're not just active in general; we're trying to work in a way that helps bring about a more just world, by participating in the movements fighting for it. The work we do is part of that contribution. But that's anathema to journalism schools, because journalism schools teach the ideology of the New York Times - that journalists may not be participants, that it compromises your objectivity. That's because those are media institutions defending the world as it is, and they don't want their employees doing this kind of work. To one degree or another, a lot of people doing this work internalize that. So it's important to bring it out into the open and talk about it, which has a lot to do with what happened to me when I started working as a writer and photographer.
Part of why it was hard to make a living was that there was no room in the media for a labor photographer and writer of this kind. I developed a relationship with an editor at the San Francisco Chronicle, and for a while I was able to write about and photograph what was happening on the border. That was a period of a lot of activity among workers organizing independent unions. There was a big, famous strike called Han Young, at the end of the '90s, in Tijuana. I was there. I'd covered it from the beginning, because I'd already been covering the settlements of workers on the outskirts of Tijuana, and the strike grew out of the struggles in those settlements. I was also close to an organization called the Coalition for Justice in the Maquiladoras, and eventually became a board member. When the strike started, I began writing about it, and for a while it was fine.
Lillian and I went to the Philippines that year, and I got in touch with a union of banana harvesters and farmworkers I already knew pretty well from here. They had a very radical union, and when we got there, they were on strike again. This was part of the land reform after Marcos fell, and they'd taken control of the plantations but still didn't control the market, or much of anything else. Dole, the big company, was basically forcing them into a situation where their poverty was worse than when they'd been Dole's employees. I covered that strike, and one year the Chronicle ran it on the front page - on Christmas, I think, because they didn't have anything else to run, but whatever, I was happy. There was this picture of a big plantation with picketing workers, and it was great.
JANNA: That was on the front page of the Chronicle?
DAVID: Yeah, but eventually this editor, Mark Abel, told me he was getting comments from other editors that I wasn't neutral enough, that I didn't spend enough time talking to the bosses, that I didn't put the point of view of the people the workers were fighting against into the articles, that I was too worker-centric. I was interested in why these workers were on strike, what was going on with them and why, and why it should matter to people in the United States. Eventually they told me I couldn't write for them anymore.
Around that same time, the UFW was organizing strawberry workers in Watsonville, and I was still close to people in the union, covering and photographing the organizing drive. I knew they were planning a huge march, and I went back to Mark and said, send me to Watsonville, I'll take pictures - this march is going to be enormous, thousands of people. And they said, no, David, you're just too pro-union, too close to the union, we can't do that. So they didn't send me. Of course, I went anyway, just not for the Chronicle.
I think the world of journalism is changing somewhat. I think there's more room today for people to be partisan and participatory in their work than there was in the 1990s. But at the time, that kind of barrier kept me in a certain position. The audience I could write for and photograph for was left-wing magazines, left-wing newspapers, or unions. And I have to give credit to the labor movement. It kept me alive during those years. They'd hire me as a photographer at a convention, for instance - sometimes pretty boring photograph, but it paid well, and it was clean work, and it told you much about who your friends were.
JANNA: And who valued your work and your perspective.
DAVID: That's right, they did. Proof of it: one year, during the Han Young strike, I was interviewing a guy in a restaurant in downtown Tijuana, and foolishly I'd left the car parked on the street. I came back and everything was gone - all my cameras, my computer, everything. The guy I was interviewing was a human rights activist who'd been threatened enough that he actually had a security guard with him - an off-duty cop named Mario. Mario said, David, they're just sending you a message. You come down to Tijuana and mess around with this strike, they'll mess around with you too. But Mario was on my side. He took me to the police station, made the official report, and said, they're probably laughing about it in the back room right now, the police did this, no question.
I never got the stuff back, not in Mexico. A cop is a cop is a cop. Mario was an interesting guy. I even wrote up his oral history at one point and put it in a book. But what happened next was, (this was right at the beginning of email), my friend Michael Eisenscher put out a message saying, David got his equipment stolen in Tijuana, he needs help. All of a sudden I was getting checks in the mail from unions like ILWU Local 8 - people saying, we like what you do, keep going. It was enough to replace everything I'd lost. You get very little feedback doing this work, considering. You wonder sometimes, does anybody read this stuff, does anybody look at these pictures, do they use it? You're putting this work out there, hoping it serves some useful function, but you wonder if it really does. And then every once in a while something happens that tells you, yes, people see it.
JANNA: I think you've touched on something I'm hoping you'll talk about more with younger people in journalism - that journalism has changed since the '90s. I always tell my students: no research is objective, no storytelling is objective. It's a fantasy that there's some neutral ground, when even in statistics, even in math, you choose your numbers, you choose how you frame a question. Scientists do this, mathematicians do this, social scientists do it, and so do humanists - photographers, writers. So let's get rid of neutrality and objectivity as a standard altogether.
But I also love that there's so much new journalism happening now, and young people feel this pressure to be quick, to hit these poignant, spicy moments, to tell a story and capture attention in thirty seconds or less. I've been talking to them about the virtue of the still photograph, of recapturing stillness, of taking the time to actually look at something. LAUSD has taken all the phones away from students when they walk into school this past year - everything goes into something called a Yonder bag, and you get it back when you leave. You can imagine the drama that's created between students and teachers, especially because a lot of the time the classroom computers don't work either, so nothing works.
But anyway - I'd love for you to speak more about where you think journalism and photography are headed, what the possibilities might be for younger people to learn from those who've been doing this work, especially in labor. I want to bring together some of these communicators from different unions - many of them already know you - and have this kind of conversation. What do you think? You said it's changing, and there are possibilities.
DAVID: Well, I like what you said about research not being objective, because you select what to research, you select your statistics, and that's exactly what a photographer does with a camera. You select. You point it here rather than there, you put this in the frame rather than that. But all of that argues for having some kind of conscious control. It's important for photographers to really look, to see what's in the image, but also to understand that we're human beings. Especially out in the world, you don't always have time to think through every image beforehand. Sometimes you do, but often you don't, and you have to rely on how you've trained your eye, your sensibilities, your politics.
Very often I'll take a series of pictures and won't actually realize everything that's in them until I see them developed. We were at Coast Guard Island in Oakland not long ago, because we'd heard ICE was coming to Oakland and was going to use the Coast Guard base. The Border Patrol came at us - we had a picket line there. They came to bring their cars into the base, got through, and then came back, and these two Border Patrol agents with pepper-spray guns shot at a minister who was simply standing in the crosswalk with his arms folded - shot him in the face. I was following them around, taking as many pictures as I could, because you could tell they were violent, they were angry, they were going to do something to us.
But it wasn't until I saw the pictures afterward that I found the key image: the gun actually going off, the spray heading toward the minister's face. It was a very dramatic picture. But I'd taken a lot of pictures before it and a lot after, and a lot of that isn't happening consciously while you're shooting. A lot of it is unconscious, or it's you following how you've trained yourself, following the timing, following your understanding of what's happening. My understanding was, I wanted to show the brutality of the Border Patrol as they were -
JANNA: - doing this to us, to people who were being completely passive.
DAVID: Right, right! Nobody had their arms up, nobody was being aggressive toward them. And once you take sides in a picture like that, it's not a neutral picture. And you really couldn't take a neutral picture in a situation like that, because anybody looking at it is going to be shocked by what's happening in it.
I think that's true of being a photographer, and I think it's true of being a written journalist too. You're always educating and training yourself, it's not a process that ever stops. There are certain practical skills you need to develop as a photographer - timing, for one. You have to learn to unconsciously predict what's going to happen in the next moment, so you're where you need to be.
JANNA: I think that's absolutely right. I'm not your traditional researcher who spends five years writing a book. I do a lot more policy research, and it has to be timely. I'm not taking both sides, usually. I'm on the worker's side. I've done a few employer studies, but I'm not very interested in that, because the story's always the same: they want the power, they want to keep the money, they want the profit. It's a capitalist agenda, we know that.
I do think a lot of young people now, seeing these injustices - this incredible, difficult moment we're living through, these fascist regimes - feel that there's a shift happening in how we do journalism and photography and documentation. I feel it in training young people to be someone who really stands by a particular principle, a value - this is where I stand, and I will lose the job, or I'll move, I'll figure it out, but I'm going to stay principled in how I do my art or my writing.
I think there's something in your story, in what you've produced and how you've worked - between working with universities, working with libraries, but mostly working with the movement - about making sure these stories go to places that will keep them. Because, as we know, worker stories don't get the endowments that business schools do. We don't have a lot of labor centers. We don't have huge endowments for worker struggles. And in photography, there are just a few photographers who've made it. What message would you give to young people who might want to do this? I work with so many of them, and I know you do too, as an organizer and as an artist. What would you tell them?
DAVID: Well, I think - and this is true for photography and for writing both - you have to keep training yourself, keep exploring. "Training" might not be quite the right word. You have to keep developing your politics, and at the same time develop your ability to use the medium you've chosen. The two go together - trying to take photographs that will move people, that have an aesthetic to them, but that also carry political meaning, where you understand and have thought about the political purpose of taking them. They all go together, and it's easy to think about only one set of those questions and not the other. You have to balance them.
It also helps to keep certain people in your head - people you think have done this well - not to model yourself on them exactly, but to see what principles guided them. As a photographer, I have a number of people in my head, but one of them is Paul Strand. Paul Strand was a very radical photographer. In the bad years of McCarthyism he left the United States and lived in France for the rest of his life, after being called before the Unamerican Committee. Strand had a whole philosophy about what makes a photograph powerful, what makes it work, and what its purpose and social value are. Without going into all his principles, I think it's important to see how they were an expression of his politics, and vice versa - how the two developed together. Aperture, the big photo-industrial complex in New York, has, I think, tried to erase Strand from history - even though he helped found Aperture to begin with - because his politics make them uncomfortable. But I think he was one of the most important thinkers about the politics of photography.
Dorothea Lange was working in the same period. She was working as a roving photographer for the Farm Security Administration. In some ways I think he was more left-wing than she was, though the photographs are very different. His were very still, slow photographs. It's funny, because part of his thinking about photography was about movement within the frame, how things move and relate to each other. But a lot of the photographs themselves are very still. Dorothea Lange, on the other hand, was very good at capturing the broader context of what was going on. But that's a good example of keeping people in your head who've worked on that balance between aesthetics and politics.
For a writer it would be the craft of writing, and at the same time, the politics of it. Who wants to read a boring essay? These days I'll read worker-centered stories, stories about struggle, and I get the feeling they're all written the same way. You lead with the human story of one person, and then you broaden out from there. It's almost become the New York Times house style - and I've used it myself. It is a classic way to organize a story -
JANNA: Point of view first.
DAVID: The human story, to draw the reader in, and then you introduce the bigger context later. After a while I start to get bored with it. I wonder, why can't we lead with the politics, make a fiery political statement first? There's a craft here, and we need to keep experimenting with different ways of writing, not get stuck doing it one way. At the same time you stay clear about the reason you're writing it in the first place, who you expect to read it, and, even more important, what you want people to do after they've read it. The same questions apply to photographers.
JANNA: You were saying something about the craft. You recently went to the San Quintín Valley, and there's a series of photos, including some from the blockade. Those are extremely powerful pictures, because of the lighting. It's night, there's a fire, there are tires. It reminds me a little of that Hansel Mieth/Otto Hagel photograph, what's going on there. Some people might not know exactly what they're looking at, but a worker, or anyone who's been in a struggle, trying to block something, can tell.
I know that in labor communications right now, there's often a fear of leading with the politics first. But these are people who are struggling. You were there, and people I know were there. I didn't go on that trip, but Lilia García-Brower, our state labor commissioner, wanted to. The kind of poverty people are living in there, and yet such dignity - you almost have to lead with the politics in a picture like that. I don't know if you want to speak to that a little - how do we keep this craft alive, keep it from getting stale?
DAVID: The pictures from the blockade happened because we were already on our way to the San Quintín Valley, in my case to document the movement of farmworkers there, including - given the times we're living in - what's happened to people who've been deported. The thing about San Quintín is that the people who do the work there - indigenous farmworkers, mostly Mixteco and Triqui - all come from the same villages in Oaxaca, and all have relatives working in the United States. So it's inseparable from migration. In fact, the whole business of H-2A recruitment, bringing people from San Quintín to the United States, is really just the newest chapter in that ongoing story of migration, and San Quintín's people are part of it.
For me, that trip had a lot of points of origin, some of it through Gaspar and the Labor Center, and the network of farmworker organizations you've helped create. But it also had another origin. For a long time I've been trying to document what happens to people after they've been deported - the consequences of U.S. migration policy. Some of that we see here in the United States, but a lot of it we don't, because it happens in Mexico or other countries.
On that trip, we had with us Alfredo "Lelo" Juárez, a farmworker organizer from Washington State who'd chosen voluntary departure after being held for three months, with no end in sight, at the Tacoma detention center, a really horrible place. He had decided to go back to Mexico. Part of what we talked about on that trip was his experience as a deported farmworker, and what he was going to do in Mexico - whether he'd have some role organizing farmworkers there, or go live in Oaxaca and work his family's farm. Those choices were right in front of him.
That highlighted other aspects of migration that came up in conversations. We had a meeting at a nursery school, and the director brought in the parents of some of the kids, who told their own stories about migration. Some talked about going to the United States as H-2A workers, what happened to them there; some about being left behind. One woman told the story of her father going to the US and never seeing him again. He stopped sending money, and when he had the chance to legalize her status, he didn't. These are all part of the impact of migration.
I'd done a story a few months before that about Tijuana, about the shelters, who was living in them, what Trump's deportation process was doing. Sometimes you find things you don't expect. I'm good friends with a professor at El Colegio de la Frontera Norte in Tijuana, Laura Velasco, and she started telling me things. I've long photographed people living in the river channel that runs through downtown Tijuana, like the LA River channel, this huge concrete wasteland where people live until the city clears them out, and then they come back. This is part of the deportation story too, because a lot of them are deportees with nowhere else to go. People get thrown across the border and find whatever shelter they can. I've spent a long time photographing that, talking to people, trying to understand how it connects to the other side of Tijuana - the explosion of the maquiladoras, and what the workers' housing looks like, given how low the wages are. It's all about poverty, in some ways.
But Laura explained a couple of things to me. First, that the housing crisis in Tijuana has gotten acute. It's so acute that even homeless people on the north side of the border, in San Diego, are coming to Tijuana now, because they can find a place to stay, or at least a meal there, when it's become much harder to do that in the US. She called that reverse migration. And there's another reverse migration, she said: people now working remotely from Tijuana. Americans can come down, find cheap housing, and work remotely, because their cost of living is lower there. That lets them get by, or make more money. But it also drives up rents in Tijuana, so now there's a homeless population there being displaced the same way you see happening in the United States.
So there I was, photographing people in food lines at the community kitchen, going to the shelters to see who was there. When Trump got elected and shut down the border, it meant, among other things, that the caravans coming up from Central America stopped. The huge population that had been living in the shelters started to shrink. Some of the shelters are half-empty now. The people still in the shelters are often coming from Tierra Caliente, from Michoacán and Guanajuato, fleeing violence inside Mexico itself, coming to the border and trying to figure out what to do next, since people can't cross anymore. The shelter becomes a way station until they can find work. And in the middle of all this, the Mexican government has told people coming from Central America: if you reach the border and can't cross, you can stay here, we'll give you status, you can find a job. The ordinary humanity of that is amazing. It's such a simple thing, and the United States can't even begin to figure out how to do it.
JANNA: Yeah - thank you for that.
DAVID: One of the things I want to say is that photographic and reporting projects, documentation projects, often go on for a long time. This one's been going on for twenty-five years, one way or another - since the Han Young strike. Even before that, I was already going down to Tijuana.
For young people today, when you're living in Los Angeles and you see ICE out on the street - or in Chicago, Minneapolis, or you're in the Bay Area waiting for them to come - that feels like such an overwhelming reality that it demands you do something. It demands that you take your camera out into the street, that you write about it, that you try to expose the brutal reality of what's happening. That's all good - that's exactly what people need to do. But first, remember that reality is going to change. What you're documenting is right here, right now, but it's also going to look different a year from now, or two years from now. That's one part of it.
What's even more important is that it can get you to ignore everything else happening in the community you live in - the things you'd ordinarily be out there documenting, if ICE weren't creating this crisis that's become almost an obsession. You have to remember: farmworkers are still working, still going on strike, still organizing. Those are still the basic material of being a participant-photographer or writer. We have to think more broadly than just the extreme issue of the moment, and also understand that we're being manipulated. First of all Trump himself is doing all of this partly so he can suck all the oxygen out of the room, so we can only think about what he wants us thinking about. But also we're manipulated by the way the media responds to it. The New York Times has nothing on its front page except ICE, until the war with Iran starts, and then it's nothing but the bombing of Tehran. We can't let ourselves be driven by the corporate media establishment - by the people who are really our enemies out there. Trump, for sure. But the New York Times, too - the New York Times is not our friend.
The purpose of being a photographer or a writer isn't to reach the apex of your career by becoming the New York Times bureau chief in Paris, which is unfortunately what journalism school teaches you is the goal. And it's not even an implied goal - it's an explicit one. The graduate journalism school in Berkeley, for instance, has built relationships with the New York Times, where students get sent out on assignments to report stories the Times may, in its wisdom, decide to publish. In the process, you're taught the New York Times way of doing things. The school puts in front of young people the idea that the reason you're doing this is to build a career, and the ultimate purpose of that career is to reach the top of the profession. If you play your cards right, cultivate the right relationships with the right editors, and don't make terrible mistakes, they can put you on that road. I think that's dishonest - well, it's not dishonest, exactly, it's honest about what it is. But it's also a kind of journalism that's going to be used against us.
To their credit, I think a lot of young people don't buy into that. I was asked to teach for a week at the Moody School of Journalism at UT Austin, and I went around talking to classes and professors, and a couple of them told me things were changing - that students no longer saw landing a great job at a daily newsroom as particularly interesting. Some seemed much more interested in new forms of communication, in becoming entrepreneurs. But some of them are the people you'll see at marches and demonstrations with their cameras, posting things to the internet right away, who see what they're doing as a way of fighting back against what they're protesting. Much closer to what we think of as participatory journalism - and these are students at one of the big J-schools in the country. That was good to see - a real antidote.
I got invited to do that through a friend who'd been hired as the DEI coordinator at the Moody School. I don't know if Celeste still has the job, but can you imagine being the DEI coordinator of a journalism school in Texas in the era of Trump?
JANNA: I have a good friend - she was at Cal State Northridge, and now she's chair of the bilingual journalism program at the University of Arizona in Tucson. She's from Peru - Jessica Retis. They've gone through a lot too, lately, being in Arizona. She's been there three or four years.
I know we've been talking a while, but there's so much here - thinking about the craft, the light, where this is all headed. I've seen it with my own students - how they want to tell stories, where they want to put their energy. I think it's good advice not to just focus on the crisis, and to keep the bigger picture in view - the ways larger forces try to shape the stories we tell, in directions that don't line up with our values. How do we resist that? I'm excited to keep thinking about this together. It's a great conversation.
DAVID: We're learning from each other.
JANNA: And it's been very rich, hearing your journey - where you've come from, how you've learned, how you've stayed with workers and taken their experience first, and then brought your craft to it. That's important for our students across every discipline, not just journalism or photography, but science, sociology, policy, whatever it is. I think these times call for exactly that.

No comments:
Post a Comment